|
Some Highlights from the
2006 Vasculitis Foundation Symposium
The biennial Vasculitis Foundation Symposium was held in Baltimore,
MD from July 7th through July 9th. This year, the Vasculitis Foundation
partnered with the Johns Hopkins University Vasculitis Center to
provide a forum for medical and scientific discussion of advances
in the field of vasculitis. The VF, formerly known as the Wegener’s
Granulomatosis Association, lived up to its new name and mission
by actively encouraging the participation of patients from all the
vasculitides. CSS was well represented with over 26 patients and
family members present at the event! Attendees were given the opportunity
to learn about the latest information about vasculitis, its treatments,
and side effects. They were inspired by reports on research trials
and encouraged and hopeful about further advances in understanding
the disease. The conference was a wealth of information, and a wonderful
opportunity for those with CSS and other vasculitic diseases to
meet each other. New friendships flourished effortlessly as CSSers
shared common stories and experiences.
The presenting physicians, who are world renown experts in their
fields, selflessly donated their time to this Symposium. They have
our heartfelt gratitude for their commitment and genuine concern
for all vasculitis patients. These wonderful doctors, deserving
special recognition and thanks, are listed below:
Dr Nabih Abdou, Dr. Robin Chernoff, Dr. Megan Clowse, Dr. Kirsten
de Groot, Dr. Ronald Falk, Dr. Paul Flint, Dr. Howard Francis, Dr.
James Garrity, Dr. Duvuru Geetha, Dr. Philp Hashkes, Dr. David Hellman,
Dr. Gary Hoffman, Dr. Eric Hoy, Dr. Sanjay Kedhar, Dr. Paul Krakovitz,
Dr. Stacey LaBahn, Dr. Carol Langford, Dr Robert Lebovics, Dr. Augustine
Lee, Dr. Robert Lorenz, Dr. Eric Matteson, Dr. Thomas McDonald,
Dr. Peter Merkel, Dr. Alicia Neu, Dr. Richard O’Brien, Dr.
Niels Rasmussen, Dr. Anthony Rosen, Dr. Philip Seo, Dr. Ulrich Specks,
Dr. John Stone, Dr. Sangeeta Sule, Dr. Michael Wechsler, and Dr.
Mark Wylam
The Symposium consisted of both breakout sessions and podium presentations.
Dr. John Stone, the Director of the Johns Hopkins University Vasculitis
Center and a member of the CSSA Medical Advisory Board, gave a podium
presentation on Saturday entitled What’s New in
Treatment. Dr. Stone spoke about Rituximab, one of
the newest and most promising treatments being studied right now.
Currently there are eight centers participating in the RAVE (Rituximab
for ANCA-associated vasculitis) trial. Although the trial is only
open to those with Wegener's or Microscopic Poyangiitis at this
time, CSS patients may be included in the not too distant future.
So far in these trials they have seen an 83% complete remission
rate in the first months the drug is given, with a 32% relapse rate
within 9-21 months. There were no significant side effects reported
in the trials. Some researchers are hopeful that this may be the
first drug that could actually replace Cytoxan, which is advantageous
since it is much less toxic.
Dr. Stone spoke about how Rituximab depletes B cells, thus disrupting
communication between B cells and T cells. It also interrupts cytokine
production, and leads to a reduction of ANCA, all of which play
a role in the autoimmune process that leads to disease. Researchers
found that for 6-12 months after treatment with Rituximab, patients
had no B cells. B cells are an important part of the immune system.
In autoimmune diseases the B cells may be behaving incorrectly leading
to vasculitis, but B cells also have a very important role in fighting
bacteria and viruses.
Later on several doctors spoke informally about a possible adverse
effect Rituximab may have on the immune system. Even though Rituximab
be a wonderful treatment for vasculitis, tampering with the immune
system could potentially bring on an immune deficiency state that
could be temporary just while using the drug, or it could permanently
alter the immune system leading to a severe immune deficiency. Many
times these treatments are a balancing act. This is especially true
in autoimmune diseases, because you can't just destroy the misbehaving
cells as you would bacteria, you have to balance the treatment to
control the abnormal behavior of the cells, while you preserve the
good function that the cell provides.
During his podium presentation, Dr. Stone also discussed Churg
Strauss specifically. He said researchers have lowered expectations
that patients with CSS will be able to get completely off steroids.
The asthma in CSS is not the “average” asthma suffered
by even severe asthmatics. The asthma of CSS is generally steroid
dependent. Even in remission, CSS patients typically require some
form of steroids throughout their lives to control their asthma.
Roughly 85% of CSS patients require ongoing low dose prednisone
just for asthma control. The remission rate for CSS with treatment
is 92%, with a relapse rate of 26%. One reason for the relatively
low rate of relapse in CSS patients may be that patients often continue
on low dose steroids to control their asthma. This low dose may
also serve to keep them in remission for their CSS.
Dr. Stone also mentioned that studies with the new biological drug
anti-IL-5 are promising for CSS. Researchers are hopeful that it
may in time prove to be a viable treatment for eosinophilic diseases.
So far the studies with anti-IL-5 for Hypereosinophilic Syndrome
have been promising, with most patients showing significant improvement.
However, anti-IL-5 used in the treatment of asthma showed that while
the drug reduced eosinophils, it had little effect on disease activity.
The drug is still in clinical trials, and is expected to get FDA
approval in the next few years.
Dr. Michael Wechsler, who also serves on the Medical Advisory Board
for the CSSA, led a well attended breakout session on Churg Strauss
on Saturday afternoon. Dr. Wechsler said that he is optimistic for
the future of those with CSS. He is finding that Methotrexate is
more useful than once believed for the treatment of CSS, and he
also reiterated the importance of steroid sparing drugs. Although
the vast majority patients with CSS remain steroid dependent, optimizing
asthma management may allow for the lowest possible dose of oral
steroid. Dr. Wechsler also discussed the Singulair issue, and whether
it had a potential role in causing CSS. He feels that studies have
shown that the use of Singulair for asthma has not been proven to
create a risk factor for CSS. The asthma associated with CSS often
warrants treatment with many different kinds of drugs. Severe asthmatics
have the greatest risk of developing CSS anyway, and the numerous
drugs used in an attempt to control asthma all came into the market
in the late 90's at the same time. It would be hard to distinguish
one as more causative than another. Dr Wechsler feels that the occurrence
of Churg Strauss syndrome in asthmatic patients receiving Singulair
appears to be related to an unmasking of an underlying vasculitic
syndrome that is initially clinically recognized as moderate to
severe asthma and treated with corticosteroids. Supporting the theory
that Singulair does not play a role in the development of CSS is
the fact that cases of pediatric CSS are extremely rare with no
rise in incidence even though this population is the largest consumer
of Singulair.
Dr. Rich O’Brien of the Johns Hopkins Department of Neurology
led a discussion on peripheral neuropathy, which affects from 60
to 80% of CSS patients. Dr. O'Brien stated that the presentation
of vasculitic neuropathy is usually rapidly progressive (within
6 months), it is asymmetric in the limbs, and it causes severe weakness.
There can be exceptions to these signs, such as the fact that 20-40%
of vasculitic neuropathies can present with a symmetric pattern
similar to the general neuropathy seen in the elderly population.
The peroneal nerve is the most commonly involved nerve, which can
cause foot drop. This nerve is the most frequently biopsied for
evidence of vasculitic neuropathy. In 30% of cases the biopsy is
normal, even though there is active disease. A combined muscle/nerve
biopsy has a significantly higher (10-20%), likelihood of showing
disease than nerve biopsy alone. The percentage of neuropathy in
each vasculitic disease varies. Active neuropathy is always treated
with prednisone, with Cytoxan added if there is multi organ involvement.
IVIG is showing promise as treatment in the neuropathic features
of these diseases. Pain management for neuropathy is an important
issue. For acute pain oxycodone or Tramadol can be used. For chronic
pain, most of the medications used cause a 50% reduction in symptoms.
Elavil, Nortriptyline, Neurontin, and newer drugs such as Lyrica,
Duloxetine, and Venlafaxine are used for chronic pain. Also, the
treatment for neuropathy is usually the treatment for the primary
disease. The prognosis for most neuropathies is usually a complete
but slow healing, with some residual numbness. It is less likely
to heal if the damage is long standing, and in an older patient.
On Sunday morning each disease group had a casual question and
answer period with an expert in their disease. The CSS group was
extremely fortunate that Dr. Gary Hoffman of the Center for Vasculitis
Care and Research at The Cleveland Clinic met with them for a round
table discussion over breakfast. Even though this session was held
at 7:00 AM, attendance was so great that CSSers overflowed the room!
Many topics were covered and Dr. Hoffman was tireless in answering
questions. One of the most important discussions centered around
the need for steroid sparing drugs in the treatment of CSS. He stated
it is best to get the steroid dose as low as possible with the aid
of an additional drug such as Imuran or Methotrexate, rather than
to stay on a dose of steroids above 10 mg/daily. Dr. Hoffman also
told us that the need for biopsy proven vasculitis is not necessary
if all the other signs of disease are there such as: high blood
eosinophils, severe asthma and sinus issues, lung infiltrates on
CT, and new numbness or joint pains. He also reiterated the importance
of being seen at leading Vasculitis Centers, because many times
disparate symptoms are not connected in a timely matter, and diagnosis
is delayed, leading to organ damage. The four centers across the
country, Boston University School of Medicine, the Cleveland Clinic
Foundation, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, and the
Mayo Clinic, are so much more familiar with the disease and recognize
the signs quickly. Also, treatment varies tremendously, so even
among teaching hospitals, patients are sometimes times treated with
high doses of steroids for too long a period of time without the
aid of steroid sparing drugs, leading to a great deal of harsh steroid
side effects. Going to the experts to begin with often saves time,
damage, and money in the long run.
Later, Sunday afternoon Dr. Hoffman wrapped up the conference with
the podium presentation Treatments, Medications, Living
with Vasculitis in the FUTURE. Dr Hoffman said that
researchers are having success in replacing the more toxic medication
Cytoxan with Methotrexate, especially in less severe cases of vasculitic
disease, resulting in fewer side effects from medication. Also recently
doctors have begun to change their recommendations for length of
Cytoxan use. Cytoxan used to be given for 1-2 years following diagnosis,
but now is being used for shorter periods of time with relatively
the same success. It is now more commonly used for 3-6 months, with
a more rapid cross over to Imuran or Methotrexate. Also, Dr. Hoffman
said that sometimes there may no initial response to Methotrexate.
Many times this treatment is then considered a failure and patients
are switched to another medication. However, if Metrotrexate is
continued, but at higher doses, it often becomes successful in treatment
of the disease.Doctors sometimes give up on it too early and move
on to more toxic medications.
After listening to all the medical experts and learning about new
research, we feel that we are at a good place in time as new information
and discoveries are coming in all the time. CSS was once almost
always a fatal disease and now the vast majority of patients are
able to achieve medically maintained remissions! Even the medical
community seems amazed at what the last 20 years of research has
brought about in the understanding and treatment of vasculitic diseases.There
is only more hope on the horizon for the development of less toxic
treatment and possibly even a cure. Patients can help in these efforts
by helping to fund research, enrolling in studies, and raising awareness
both in the general public and among young doctors and researchers.
These were just a few of the topics presented at the Symposium
that were relevant to CSS patients. For a complete listing visit
the VF
web site. CSSers were pleased to be able to participate in this
Symposium and are already making plans to attend the next VF Symposium,
which is being planned in conjunction with the Mayo Clinic and scheduled
for the Summer of 2008.
The CSSA would like to extend sincere thanks to Vasculitis Foundation,
including its' members and its' Board of Directors for opening the
Symposium to all vasculitis patients, and to all the volunteers
who helped make the Symposium possible, including the Kullman family,
and especially to the medical professionals who gave so generously
of their time. In addition, the CSSA is very grateful for the interest
and participation of so many CSS patients and their families. We
look forward meeting old friends and making new ones at the 2008
VF Symposium at the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota.
Happy
CSS Participants at the Symposium |
 |
 |
|